Carla and Tom Cosenzi Are Carrying On a Proud Legacy
Carla and Tom Cosenzi both say they were destined for careers in the auto industry — although she briefly flirted with thoughts of doing something else. However, they found themselves leading the Tommy Car Corp. far sooner than they could have imagined following their father’s valiant but unsuccessful fight against brain cancer. They endured an extreme trial by fire — the Great Recession and its profound impact on this sector — and emerged from it with confidence and plans for future expansion.Carla Cosenzi remembers, as a youngster, watching and listening to the TV and radio commercials for her grandfather’s car dealerships — and grimacing.
Indeed, what she remembers most about the spots, usually featuring sales-oriented banter between her grandfather, Thomas A. Cosenzi, and his wife, Sandy, is that they weren’t very good — at least from an artistic-quality standpoint — in her estimation.
“They were a little obnoxious; they stood out, let’s put it that way, and people still remember them all these years later,” Cosenzi told BusinessWest. “Sandy was always saying things like, ‘take the deal, Tom!’”
Today, it’s Carla’s voice and face being featured in ads for Country Nissan in Hadley; Country Hyundai in Greenfield; and Patriot Pontiac, Buick, GMC in Charleton, dealerships she manages with her brother, Thomas M. Cosenzi, who doesn’t want anything to do with cameras and microphones. She believes these ads are of much better quality — although there are still large amounts of that car-selling hype and hyperbole, and phrases like ‘it’s cheaper in Charleton’ — than those from two generations ago, and she knows they generate results.
But she also believes there’s much more to the ongoing success of the emerging auto group known as Tommy Car Corp., which she serves as president, than her proficiency as a pitchperson.
Having the right cars, especially Hyundai, which is experiencing an explosion in popularity, at the right time, and in the right places — Route 9 in Hadley has worked for the Nissan store since it moved there in 2007, but Greenfield has been an effective location for Hyundai — certainly helps, she explained. As do an experienced workforce and considerable improvement in the market since the unprecedented turmoil of 2008 and 2009.
But there are also the vast sums of experience, instinct, and entrepreneurial drive handed down from the preceding generations, and especially from her father, Thomas E. Cosenzi. He groomed the third generation, and, more specifically, coaxed Carla into the business after she earned degrees in clinical psychology from Northeastern and Columbia and entertained thoughts about pursuing that field in some way. And he provided both inspiration and invaluable lessons in life and business as he waged and ultimately lost a battle with brain cancer.
“I fought it for a little while, thinking I was going to do something on my own,” Carla, 31, said of the car industry and her career options. “But the more time I spent in the business, the more I fell in love with it. And it’s a great opportunity to carry on my dad’s legacy.”
The brother-sister tandem is doing this legacy work at an intriguing time for the industry, and, in fact, they really started running things just before the auto industry — and the rest of the economy, for that matter — was turned upside down by the Great Recession, when buyers stayed away and many dealerships went dark.
Living through that ultra-rugged indoctrination — and actually doing much better than merely surviving — gave the Consenzis a large dose of confidence that has played a factor in their current success, said Carla, adding that cutting their teeth in such fashion has steeled them against adversity and positioned them for the better times.
“That’s all we know of the business, and I’m not sure that’s a good thing or a bad thing,” she said of taking the helm at the business during arguably the most trying period in the history of the auto industry. “We think it’s a good thing, because we feel that, if we were this successful in a bad economic period, then it can only get better for us.”
And while the current picture is appealing for the Tommy Car group, the Cosenzis have one eye on the future and a likely course of expansion.
“We’ve finished our settling-in period; we’re young, aggressive, and we want to grow,” said Carla, noting that an informal five-year plan calls for adding more dealerships to the group.
But Tom, just 26, stressed that growth will be of the controlled variety, and that expansion will come where, when, and how it makes good business sense.
“We want to make sure, when we take advantage of an opportunity, that it’s the right opportunity,” he explained, adding that expansion could occur inside the 413 area code, outside, or perhaps both.
For this issue and its focus on auto sales, BusinessWest looks at an emerging success story within the local car market, one that appears to be hitting on all cylinders.
It’s All Relative
Like many second- or third-generation dealership managers, the Consenzis have been around cars for as long as they can remember, and they learned the business from the bottom up, inside and out.
“We worked during the summers, especially when we were home from college,” Carla recalled. “And if we worked for our dad … he was very strict with us. He worked us like we weren’t family; ‘you worked like everyone else, or you didn’t work for me,’ that was his motto.”
Tracing the family history in the auto industry, Carla said her father and grandfather were both in the business, but not together.
Thomas A. Cosenzi eventually had several dealerships in the region, including Springfield Lincoln Mercury, Country Jeep Eagle in Agawam, and Country Nissan in Greenfield, which he sold to his son, who managed to forge his own identity in the business.
“My dad started reconditioning cars and then buying and selling cars at auction,” said Carla. “He opened a small used-car dealership in Agawam, and then got an opportunity to get a Chrysler dealership, and then he just grew from there.
“He had seven or eight franchises at one point,” she continued, noting that the group stretched across Western Mass.. “He was known for seizing on opportunities whenever the timing was right.”
He also brought the third-generation into the business, an assignment that was much easier with his son, who knew early on that he wanted to make cars his career.
Meanwhile, Carla, once brought back into dealership management not long after earning her master’s from Columbia in 2004, put aside thoughts of pursuing clinical psychology and focused instead on helping her father expand the Tommy Group.
However, the management-succession process was tragically hastened by her father’s illness and death two years ago.
Indeed, Thomas M. Cosenzi, who was in college when his father’s brain tumor was detected in early 2007, returned home to help run the business, and over the course of the next few years, the helm was slowly transferred.
And for the most part, it was a very smooth transition.
“Surprisingly, it was a relatively easy process,” Carla explained. “We work very well together and split all the responsibilities; we consult each other on any major decisions we’re making. Some people are shocked at how easy a transition it was and how well we function as brother and sister.”
But while the transition was smooth, the seas they transitioned into were quite rough. Carla said the Tommy Group navigated through them by essentially focusing on the horizon and not getting too caught up in the difficult moment.
“We kept ourselves in a bubble, stayed focused, and didn’t let what was going on outside the stores affect how we were running the business,” she explained. “And it paid off; we’re doubled our Nissan sales, and our Hyundai franchise is doing great.
“We stayed positive throughout the dealerships, and especially in the sales department,” she continued, “and came up with creative methods to get people through the doors.”
Staging a Coupe
One of those methods was more aggressive marketing, part of an overall rebranding effort, said Tom, noting that Carla’s omnipresence on the airways starting a few years ago has helped build greater awareness of the Country name in the Western Mass. marketplace.
“It’s definitely helped get our name out there,” he explained. “People know Country, and they know Carla.”
Indeed, like other area dealership managers with a strong media presence, Carla said the messages help build connections that often translate into trust — and sales.
“I think they work because people hear me, and then when they come in the showroom they can see me — I’m there, on the floor,” she said, adding that that there are more people coming into the dealerships these days, even if traffic is still off considerably from the days before the recession.
There are some lingering effects from the downturn and other recent events, such as the March tsunami in Japan, which have challenged some dealers (see related story, page 22), but Tommy Car Corp. is having a solid 2011, she noted, and the outlook for the future is bright.
There are a number of factors that go into the current performance as well as that forecast, said Tom, listing everything from the locations of the dealerships to the success of the car brands, especially Hyundai, to those aforementioned marketing efforts.
Elaborating, he said that the move from a much smaller location on Colrain Road in Greenfield to the site on Route 9, only a few miles from both Amherst and Northampton, has benefited the dealership, giving it those highly valued qualities known as access and visibility.
And with the five colleges so near, the Cosenzis are expecting that they will undoubtedly see a great deal of interest in Nissan’s Leaf, an electric vehicle. For now, though, and for probably some time, all interested parties can do is test-drive the vehicle at the dealership and order one from Nissan.
“It’s an exciting development — this is the only all-electric car,” said Tom. “This is going to spark interest in Nissan again, and we think we’re going to be in the right place to sell the Leaf.”
Meanwhile, Greenfield remains an effective location for the Hyundai dealership, said Carla, drawing customers from Hampshire County in Massachusetts and both Southern Vermont and Southern New Hampshire.
“Greenfield is a great community, and our location is right off the highway,” Carla explained. “So it’s easily accessible from Keene and Brattleboro. And while some people say that people don’t drive north, we don’t see that; we see that customers will drive from Hadley, Northampton, Amherst, and even Springfield.”
However, Hyundai has been so successful in recent years that maintaining adequate inventory has been a challenge, said Carla.
“We get an Elantra in, it hits the ground, and we sell it,” she said of the carmaker’s compact, gas-sipping model. “We sell it before the service department even has a chance to go through it because people really want them. Elantras, Accents, Sonatas … you can’t get your hands on them. We’ve learned to survive on a much shorter supply.”
As for possible expansion, the Cosenzis say they will emulate their father and seize opportunities when, where, and if the situation is right.
“We’re very careful to make sure that the stores we have are running the way we want them to run, that they’re profitable and properly staffed,” said Carla. “And we think we’re at that point. We’ll look at any opportunity that comes our way.”
On the Spot
When BusinessWest sought out some pictures of the Cozenzis, Tom deferred to his sister at first. “She’s the one who gets in front of the camera,” he explained.
Eventually, he acquiesced. After all, these siblings are most definitely a team, one that has withstood challenges of many different kinds, emerging stronger and more confident in the process.
And with radio and television commercials that stand out — in this case, for the right reasons.
George O’Brien can be reached at obrien@businesswest.com


























