Page 24 - BusinessWest July 10, 2023

Employers, Take Notice
Former Employees Win More Than $20 Million in Two Cases
BY JOHN S. GANNON, ESQ.
“Employers cold to the idea of reducing legal risk by paying severance ought to be mindful
of cautionary tales about the penny-wise but pound-foolish.”
Afew weeks ago, Starbucks was in all the employment- law headlines, but not for good reasons. Given the publicity, you may have heard about the case of former Starbucks employee Shannon Phillips, who worked in the Philadelphia area. Phillips was a white Starbucks employee who claimed she was fired because of her race. The jury agreed and ordered the coffee giant to pay her $25.6 million in damages.
What you may not have heard about was a more local
case in which a Massachusetts employee was awarded more than $24 million by a jury who found she was discriminated against because of her mental health. Here are some details about those two cases, followed by some commentary on what these employers could have done to possibly avoid the massive judgments.
Phillips v. Starbucks Corp.
Shannon Phillips, who is a Caucasian female, began her employment with Starbucks in 2005. She started at the company as a district manager and was promoted in 2011 to regional director of Operations for ‘Area 71,’ which included all stores in Philadelphia and several suburbs near the city.
On April 12, 2018, a Starbucks location in Philadelphia made national news when two African-American patrons who were having a business meeting there were arrested for trespassing. The event sparked protests throughout the Philadelphia area.
Starbucks later reached a settlement with the two men
and issued a public statement that “Starbucks will continue to take actions that stem from this incident to repair and reaffirm our values and vision for the kind of company that we want to be.” Because she was the regional director of Operations for the Philadelphia area, Phillips was called upon by Starbucks leadership to support and implement their post-incident efforts. According to Starbucks, however, she displayed poor leadership and “failed to perform the essential functions of her role as regional director” after the April 2018 incident. As a result, she was fired.
Phillips sued Starbucks for race discrimination, saying her Caucasian race played a role in the decision to terminate her employment. In her complaint, Phillips said she “worked tirelessly” to help Starbucks repair its image after the event in Philadelphia, but that the chain’s attempts to repair community relations resulted in discrimination against white employees. The jury agreed and awarded her $25.6 million, which was mostly comprised of punitive damages (damages assessed in order to punish a defendant when the behavior is found to be especially harmful or malicious).
Menninger v. PPD Dev., LP
Dr. Lisa Menninger worked as the executive director of a global laboratory-
services company. Her job included operational
Employees
Continued on page 28
>>
Experience Matters. Experience Skoler Abbott.
For almost 60 years, businesses across Massachusetts have relied on Skoler Abbott’s experience in all areas of labor and employment law, including:
v Legalcompliancereviews,opinionsandadvice
v Zealousdefenseandadvocacyingovernment investigations, administrative proceedings and litigation
v Laborrelationsdisputes,arbitrationsand collective bargaining
v Staff and supervisor training on wage/hour laws, leave management, harassment, etc.
Put our experience to work for you.
One Monarch Place Springfield, MA 01144 P 413.737.4753 SKOLER-ABBOTT.COM
Oh honey...
Kick pests out for good.
413-566-8222 | GraduatePestSolutions.com
24 JULY 10, 2023
<< LAW >>
BusinessWest