Editorial

Not a Sublime Turn of Events

Leaders at Sublime Systems, a company that has developed a low-carbon cement, believe they can withstand the loss of an $87 million federal grant and move their plans forward, including those for a manufacturing plant in Holyoke.

News of the Trump administration’s plans to terminate $3.7 billion in grants issued by the the U.S. Department of Energy’s Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations, including the $87 million earmarked for Sublime, came down earlier this month.

To many, the news sounded like a death knell for Sublime, but officials there believe they have enough momentum, in the form of contracts with players ranging from Microsoft to regional and national construction companies, including Daniel O’Connell’s Sons in Holyoke, to press on and perhaps only be slowed down, not stopped, by the loss of the federal grant.

We hope they’re right, because Sublime’s ability to weather this storm has huge implications for both Holyoke and the region.

Before getting to that, we’ll just say that the termination of this grant makes little sense. The Trump administration has stated goals to bring more manufacturing to this country and lessen its dependence on foreign countries for everything from energy to construction materials.

Sublime’s cement does all that. It will bring jobs here, and it will reduce dependence on foreign makers of cement, including Canada and Mexico.

We can only assume it is the phrase ‘clean energy’ that does not align with the philosophy and goals of the Trump administration, but the ‘why’ in this case is not what matters. It’s the end result.

Now, Sublime must try to resecure that federal grant by restating its already strong case about what its product can do to dramatically reduce the carbon footprint from cement making, while also creating jobs and helping to revitalize a community like Holyoke.

The Paper City has a lot riding on Sublime’s ability to move forward with plans to construct a plant in the Flats section of the city that will produce 30,000 tons of cement per year. Indeed, the city is trying to stake a claim as a home to clean-tech companies, and brings many assets to bear, including land and former mills to develop and reliable, cheap, green energy (hydropower) from the Holyoke G&E.

With the cannabis sector plateauing, if not declining, Holyoke needs clean energy and companies like Sublime for job creation to help continue the momentum that has been building in this historic manufacturing city for several years now.

The region needs Sublime and other success stories in this realm as well. We’ve already documented how its traditional economic pillars — higher education, healthcare, and nonprofits — were already struggling before the Trump administration began changing policies and terminating grants, and now, their struggles are deepening. The region needs to tap new sources of innovation and jobs, and clean energy is one of them.

It’s very difficult for a company like Sublime to overcome the loss of an $87 million grant. It must tap other resources — from the state to venture capital — while also hoping to get that grant back.

We hope Sublime can overcome this loss and move forward, because Holyoke and this region need this company to succeed.